An employer can have a legitimate reason to end an employment relationship and still make the resulting claim unnecessarily expensive. The supervisor remembers repeated problems, but the evaluations are glowing. HR has the personnel file, but the relevant messages disappeared when IT closed the employee’s account. A demand letter sits unanswered while everyone waits to see whether the employee will sue. An employee with relevant information leaves the employer, and their records are not maintained.

These problems can arise even when the original decision was lawful. For employment practices liability (EPL) insurers, brokers, and risk managers, they present opportunities to help insureds manage costs before disputes escalate. The following ten mistakes illustrate where employers can lose control of an otherwise manageable claim. The appropriate response will depend on the circumstances, applicable law, and the employer’s insurance coverage.

1. Waiting until termination to document performance

A termination memo may be difficult to reconcile with years of favorable performance reviews. When supervisors raise concerns, contemporaneous documentation can help explain the problem and the employee’s response. Specific examples are generally more useful than labels such as “bad attitude.”

Before approving a termination, HR can compare the proposed reason with existing records. An unexplained inconsistency deserves attention, although a discrepancy does not necessarily establish discrimination or retaliation. The EEOC’s retaliation guidance recognizes that shifting explanations may support an inference of pretext, while credible explanations may undermine that inference.

Employers should avoid backdating records or presenting a later recollection as contemporaneous. A subsequent memorandum can be useful when it accurately identifies when the account was prepared and the information on which it relies.

2. Skipping the comparison with other employees

An employee’s policy violation may justify discipline, but comparable treatment can still matter to the evaluation of a discrimination claim. How did the employer respond to other employees whose conduct was similar?

Consider an employer that issues a final warning to one employee but terminates another for an apparently similar violation. Employers do not need to impose identical discipline for every violation. They should, however, be prepared to explain why employees who engaged in similar conduct received different treatment. There may be legitimate reasons for the different outcomes, including differences in their disciplinary history, job responsibilities, training, or the nature or severity of the underlying conduct.

The EEOC’s guidance on retaliation discusses evidence concerning comparative treatment. A focused review before a significant disciplinary decision may help employers identify distinctions that can later be explained with contemporaneous evidence.

3. Treating a complaint as a management inconvenience

A harassment complaint should not be ignored because the reporting employee is difficult to manage or the accused supervisor performs well. Employers may reduce risk by offering employees multiple avenues to report, including a way to raise concerns outside the immediate chain of command.

The EEOC recommends prompt, impartial investigations that are sufficiently thorough to address the allegations. The appropriate scope will depend on the complaint and the information reasonably available to the employer. For example, a narrow factual dispute may require fewer interviews than competing accounts of serious misconduct. When evidence points in different directions, an additional interview may prove worthwhile. Documenting the reason for the employer’s response can help a later reviewer understand how it reached its decision.

4. Closing the investigation without monitoring retaliation

An investigation’s conclusion may not end the employer’s exposure. A complainant’s opposition to perceived discrimination can be protected even if the underlying allegation is not ultimately substantiated. Under the EEOC’s retaliation guidance, opposition generally must rest on a reasonable, good-faith belief and be conducted in a reasonable manner. The analysis may differ for participation in an EEOC proceeding.

Following a complaint, HR should monitor and pay particular attention to significant employment decisions involving the complainant or participating witnesses. That does not mean every subsequent change is suspicious, but the employer should understand the reasons for its decisions.

Protection against retaliation does not exempt an employee from legitimate performance standards. Managers can continue ordinary supervision, while involving HR when a sensitive decision would benefit from an independent review.

5. Assuming exhausted leave permits automatic termination

Exhaustion of Family and Medical Leave Act leave does not necessarily resolve the employer’s obligations under other laws. In some circumstances, additional leave may be a reasonable accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act. The EEOC’s employer-provided leave guidance describes that possibility, subject to eligibility, the circumstances of the request, and undue hardship. Governing court decisions and state or local laws also require consideration.

Before separating an employee who cannot return when protected leave ends, an employer may need to explore whether an effective accommodation is available. An individualized assessment can address the anticipated duration of leave and the actual effect on operations. Undue hardship should be assessed under the applicable legal standard, not assumed from the employer’s inconvenience.

Supervisors should also recognize potential requests for FMLA leave. As the Department of Labor explains, an employee seeking FMLA-qualifying leave for the first time need not invoke the statute by name, but must provide enough information to put the employer on notice of a potentially qualifying reason. A benefits administrator’s determination does not necessarily answer every accommodation question.

6. Preserving the personnel file but losing the evidence

The personnel file may contain only part of the relevant record. Text messages, workplace communication platforms, and electronic scheduling systems may hold information bearing on a dispute. Some of it may be removed through routine account closure or device replacement.

When litigation is reasonably anticipated, employers should consult counsel about the scope of any preservation obligation and practical steps to address relevant sources. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37(e) addresses the loss of electronically stored information that should have been preserved for litigation. Whether sanctions are available depends on the circumstances, including whether the employer took reasonable preservation steps and whether the information can be restored or replaced. The rule imposes additional requirements for its most severe sanctions.

A preservation process may involve relevant personnel and IT systems, but its scope should be proportionate to the matter. The aim is not to retain every conceivable record indefinitely. Counsel also needs to understand evidence unfavorable to the defense rather than collecting only documents supporting the employer’s account.

7. Sending a response before testing the facts

An employer’s early description of an employment dispute may be compared with later testimony and documentary evidence. Responses to administrative charges, demand letters, or unemployment proceedings therefore deserve factual review appropriate to the circumstances.

The EEOC’s position-statement procedures encourage respondents to address the allegations with relevant documents and specific factual support. The agency also explains that position statements and nonconfidential attachments may be disclosed to charging parties on request. Before submission, it is worth checking material assertions against the available record and identifying unresolved disputes rather than treating every allegation as conclusively disproved.

An inconsistency does not always mean someone has been untruthful. A witness may recall events differently or new information may emerge. Employers can explain those circumstances accurately while meeting applicable deadlines and considering extensions when warranted.

8. Waiting for a lawsuit to review notice obligations

Under some EPL policies, a written demand or administrative charge may qualify as a claim before a lawsuit is filed. Other policies use different definitions and reporting provisions, and the consequences of late notice can depend on both the policy language and governing law.

Employers may reduce avoidable coverage disputes by promptly routing potentially covered matters to whoever handles insurance reporting. The relevant review should examine the issued policy’s definition of a claim, when notice is due, and how notice must be delivered. Some policies also provide a mechanism for reporting circumstances that might later give rise to a claim.

It is risky to assume that notice to a broker necessarily satisfies the insurer’s requirements or that reporting can always await the completion of an internal investigation. Whether notice is sufficient is a policy-specific and potentially jurisdiction-specific question.

9. Spending or negotiating before checking consent requirements

Before retaining defense counsel or making a settlement offer, an employer should review the policy’s defense and consent provisions. The employer’s actual policy and applicable law will determine its obligations.

Early discussions with the insurer may help clarify defense responsibilities and counsel rates. The employer and insurer should also understand how settlement authority will be obtained. Whether defense costs erode limits, and how any retention applies, depends on the actual coverage terms.

Coverage coordination should occur without allowing a response or litigation deadline to pass. Even when the parties disagree about funding or counsel selection, prompt attention to procedural obligations remains important.

10. Confusing a defensible case with an inexpensive case

A strong merits position does not guarantee an inexpensive defense. Discovery costs may rise as additional witnesses are identified or documents reveal disputed facts. For that reason, an early case assessment can consider the likely expense of litigation alongside the merits and potential exposure.

Counsel may be able to provide a staged budget and identify which factual developments would materially change the valuation. The assessment should be revisited as evidence emerges, rather than treated as fixed at the outset.

Early resolution can make business sense in some cases, including through the EEOC’s voluntary mediation program when available. In others, the legal, financial, or institutional considerations may support a sustained defense. Neither settlement nor litigation should be automatic. Decisions should reflect the particular matter and any applicable insurer approval requirements.

Before the Next Claim Arrives

Brokers and risk managers can help employers identify potential problems by asking a few questions about how employment decisions are made and how claims are handled.

  • Who reviews significant disciplinary decisions for supporting evidence and potentially relevant comparisons?
  • How do complaints reach someone who can evaluate them, and what follow-up occurs after an investigation?
  • Can HR and IT preserve relevant electronic records before routine deletion or employee offboarding?
  • Who reviews potential claims for insurance reporting obligations and any required consent?
  • When will the employer, counsel, and insurer revisit the likely cost of litigation and possible resolution?

Employers cannot eliminate every employment claim, nor can they control every expense that follows. They can, however, make better decisions about how they document employment actions and respond when disputes arise. For insurers and risk managers, helping employers establish those practices before a claim develops may be one of the more practical ways to reduce unnecessary defense costs.

Meet the Author

Headshot of Leo Tyree

Leo Tyree

Senior Counsel, Constangy, Brooks, Smith & Prophete

Leo Tyree is Senior Counsel at Constangy, Brooks, Smith & Prophete, where she represents employers in employment litigation and advises on workplace investigations, regulatory compliance, and employment-related risk management. She previously served as a Senior Trial Attorney in the Federal Trade Commission’s Bureau of Competition.

News Type

PLUS Blog

Business Line

Employment Practices Liability (EPL), Professional Liability

Contribute to

PLUS Blog

Contribute your thoughts to the PLUS Membership consisting of 45,000+ Professional Liability Practitioners.

Related Podcasts

Related Articles

November 6, 2026

The Wait is Over: The 2026 PLUS Conference Starts Tomorrow!

The 2026 PLUS Conference, officially kicking off tomorrow, November 10 through the…

November 4, 2026

Professional Liability Underwriting Society Announces the 2026 PLUS Emerging Leader Award Recipients

The Professional Liability Underwriting Society (PLUS) is pleased to announce the recipients…